Award-winning restaurant featuring authentic, unique, Italian and Mediterranean cuisine.
Address
Info :
Follow Us
You get a dedicated private dining space for up to 45 guests, complete with a full-service bar and stress-free coordination that handles every detail. Your birthday celebration becomes the kind of evening where everyone feels special, the food exceeds expectations, and you actually get to enjoy your own party.
No more worrying about whether we can accommodate your group size or dietary needs. No more settling for generic chain restaurant birthday experiences. You get authentic Italian cuisine prepared with organic ingredients, live saxophone jazz music, and staff who bring out complimentary birthday cake without you even asking.
We’ve been serving families throughout the Shirley area since 2004, creating the kind of birthday celebrations that become family traditions. Founded by Anna Mountzuris, our award-winning Italian restaurant brings authentic Abruzzese and Mediterranean cuisine to your special occasions.
What makes us different is the combination of old-world Italian hospitality with modern convenience. You get homemade pasta, fresh seafood, and signature dishes like our renowned veal chop, all prepared with the same attention to detail whether you’re celebrating a child’s birthday or a milestone anniversary.
Our 4.5-star reputation comes from consistently delivering experiences that feel both elegant and comfortable—the kind of place where Shirley families know they can bring three generations together and everyone leaves happy.
Start with a simple phone call or online reservation. Our team coordinates your private dining experience, working with you to customize the menu based on your group’s preferences and any dietary restrictions.
On the day of your celebration, you’re escorted to our private upstairs dining room—a space designed specifically for special occasions with its own full-service bar. Our kitchen prepares each dish to order using fresh, natural ingredients, while the live saxophone jazz music creates the perfect backdrop for conversation and celebration.
The evening flows seamlessly from appetizers through dessert, with your server managing timing so you can focus on your guests. When it’s time for the birthday surprise, the complimentary cake appears with candles lit, creating that perfect moment everyone will remember.
Ready to get started?
Your birthday party package includes exclusive use of our private upstairs dining room, accommodating up to 45 guests for seated dining or 55 for cocktail-style celebrations. The space features a dedicated full-service bar, ensuring your guests never wait for drinks.
Our customizable menu showcases Tartufo’s signature dishes—think lobster ravioli in vodka pink sauce, bone-in veal chop stuffed with prosciutto and fontina, or the classic homemade tagliatelle carbonara. Every dish is prepared using organic meats, fresh vegetables, and ingredients sourced according to authentic Italian traditions.
Shirley residents particularly appreciate our attention to local preferences—our French and Italian influences reflect the area’s heritage, while our warm, family-friendly atmosphere accommodates everything from children’s birthday parties to sophisticated adult celebrations. The complimentary birthday cake service and stress-free coordination mean you get all the special touches without any of the planning headaches.
Our private upstairs dining room accommodates up to 45 guests for seated birthday dinners and up to 55 people for cocktail-style birthday celebrations. This space is completely separate from the main restaurant, giving your party privacy and exclusivity.
The room includes a full-service bar, so your guests can enjoy cocktails, wine, or beer without waiting. If you have a larger group, we can work with you to explore options using multiple areas of the restaurant, though the private dining room is the most popular choice for birthday celebrations.
Yes, we provide complimentary birthday cake and candle service for birthday celebrations—often without you even needing to request it. Our staff pays attention to special occasions and takes pride in creating those memorable moments that make birthdays special.
If you prefer to bring your own cake or have specific dietary requirements for the birthday dessert, just let us know when making your reservation. We’re experienced in accommodating various dietary needs and can work with you to ensure the birthday person gets exactly what they want for their special day.
Absolutely. We have extensive experience accommodating dietary restrictions and food allergies for birthday parties and private events. When you make your reservation, discuss any dietary needs with our staff—we’ll work with you to customize the menu accordingly.
We prepare everything made-to-order using fresh, natural ingredients, which gives us flexibility to modify dishes. Whether you have guests who are gluten-free, vegetarian, or have specific food allergies, our kitchen can adapt the authentic Italian recipes to ensure everyone at your birthday celebration can enjoy the meal safely.
For our private dining room, we recommend booking at least 2-3 weeks in advance, especially for weekend celebrations or during busy seasons. Popular dates like weekends and holiday periods fill up quickly since there’s only one private dining space.
However, we’re known for being accommodating—if you have a last-minute birthday celebration, call anyway. We’ve successfully handled walk-in birthday parties in the past and will work with you to find a solution, even if it means arranging a special section in the main dining room with personalized service.
Our private dining room rental includes exclusive use of the upstairs space, dedicated service staff, full bar access, and complimentary birthday cake and candle service. You pay for food and beverages based on what your guests order, with the option to create custom menus or prix fixe packages.
We provide stress-free coordination and planning assistance at no additional charge—we’ll help you plan timing, discuss menu options, and handle special requests. There’s no separate room rental fee; the cost is based on your food and beverage selections, making it an excellent value for the level of service and privacy you receive.
Yes, we feature live saxophone jazz music, which creates a sophisticated and celebratory atmosphere perfect for birthday parties. The music adds an elegant touch to your celebration without being so loud that it interferes with conversation.
Our live music typically happens on certain evenings—Tuesday nights are particularly popular for the saxophone performances. When booking your birthday party, ask about the music schedule if live entertainment is important to your celebration. The combination of authentic Italian cuisine, private dining, and live jazz creates a truly memorable birthday experience.
Local Resources
Useful Links