Seafood Restaurant in Pinehurst, MA

Authentic Italian Seafood Done Right

Fresh Mediterranean flavors meet traditional Italian techniques in every dish we serve in Pinehurst, MA.
Juicy grilled prawns garnished with fresh herbs and a lemon slice, perfect for seafood lovers.
Succulent shrimp prepared with rich truffle flavor on a white plate.

Fine Dining Seafood Restaurant Pinehurst, MA

What Real Italian Seafood Tastes Like

You know the difference between good seafood and great seafood. Great seafood doesn’t mask its freshness with heavy sauces or shortcuts. It celebrates the ocean’s natural flavors through careful preparation and authentic technique.

That’s exactly what you get at our Pinehurst, MA location. We prepare each seafood dish using traditional Abruzzese and Mediterranean methods passed down through generations. Fresh catches are transformed into signature dishes like our renowned Grilled Calamari and house-made seafood pasta that locals have been talking about for over two decades.

Every bite delivers the clean, vibrant taste that only comes from quality ingredients treated with respect. No frozen substitutes. No artificial flavors. Just authentic Italian seafood the way it was meant to be experienced.

Italian Restaurant With Seafood Pinehurst, MA

Two Decades of Authentic Excellence

Since 2004, we’ve been serving the Pinehurst, MA community the kind of Italian seafood that reminds you why you fell in love with Mediterranean cuisine in the first place. Founded by Anna Mountzuris with a deep commitment to authentic Abruzzese traditions, our kitchen has earned its reputation one perfectly prepared dish at a time.

We source only the finest organic ingredients and prepare everything to order. Our 4.5-star reputation isn’t built on marketing—it’s built on consistency, quality, and the kind of warm hospitality that makes you feel like family from the moment you walk through our doors.

The live saxophone music on select evenings and our carefully curated wine selection create the perfect backdrop for everything from intimate date nights to milestone celebrations that Pinehurst, MA residents have come to expect from fine dining.

Fresh salad with truffle, tomatoes, olives, feta, and mixed greens, drizzled with dressing for a gourmet Tartufo experience.

Best Seafood Restaurant Pinehurst, MA

From Ocean to Table, Done Right

Great seafood starts with great sourcing. We hand-select the freshest catches, working with trusted New England suppliers who understand Massachusetts waters and share our commitment to quality. Each delivery is inspected to ensure it meets our exacting standards before it ever touches our kitchen.

We then apply traditional Italian techniques that have been perfected over generations. Whether it’s our signature Grilled Calamari or house-made lobster ravioli, every dish is prepared to order using authentic methods that preserve and enhance the natural flavors of the sea.

The final step happens at your table, where our knowledgeable staff can guide you through wine pairings and share the story behind each dish. You’re not just getting dinner in Pinehurst, MA—you’re experiencing the passion and tradition that goes into every plate we serve.

Delicious salmon fillet seasoned with tartufo truffle, served with fresh salad and lemon wedge on a green plate.

Explore More Services

About Tartufo

Premium Seafood Restaurant Pinehurst, MA

More Than Dinner, It's an Experience

Your dining experience includes access to our full range of authentic Italian seafood specialties, from traditional antipasti featuring the freshest shellfish to our signature pasta dishes that showcase the Mediterranean’s finest flavors. Our menu changes seasonally to highlight the best available catches while maintaining the classic dishes that have made us a Pinehurst, MA favorite.

Massachusetts diners appreciate restaurants that understand the local palate while delivering authentic international cuisine. Our location in Pinehurst, MA puts us at the heart of a community that values both tradition and quality—exactly what we’ve been delivering for over two decades. The area’s sophisticated dining scene demands excellence, and we’ve consistently met that standard.

We also offer private dining accommodations for up to 45 guests, full catering services throughout the Pinehurst, MA area, and an extensive wine program featuring selections that perfectly complement our seafood-focused menu. Whether you’re planning an intimate dinner for two or a celebration for the whole family, we have the experience and expertise to make it memorable.

Savory chicken fillet with truffle oil, served with greens and a rich sauce on white plate.

What makes your seafood restaurant different from other Italian restaurants in Pinehurst, MA?

We specialize exclusively in authentic Abruzzese and Mediterranean seafood preparation, using traditional techniques that have been passed down through generations. Unlike restaurants that treat seafood as just another menu category, we’ve built our entire reputation around doing it right for the Pinehurst, MA community.

Our founder Anna Mountzuris brought authentic Italian seafood traditions to Massachusetts over 20 years ago, and we’ve maintained those standards ever since. We source only the finest organic ingredients, prepare everything to order, and never compromise on quality—even when it costs more.

The result is seafood that tastes like what you’d find in the coastal regions of Italy, not the heavy, sauce-laden dishes that pass for Italian seafood at many restaurants in the area.

Absolutely. We understand that seafood allergies and dietary restrictions are serious concerns, and our kitchen is equipped to handle special requests safely and deliciously for all our Pinehurst, MA guests.

We can modify most dishes to accommodate gluten-free, dairy-free, and other dietary needs without sacrificing flavor. We also offer several naturally gluten-free seafood preparations that showcase the pure taste of fresh fish and shellfish sourced from New England waters.

When you make your reservation, just let us know about any allergies or dietary restrictions, and we’ll work with you to create a dining experience that’s both safe and satisfying. Our staff is trained to understand ingredients and preparation methods, so you can dine with confidence.

Our signature Grilled Calamari is what put us on the map—it’s prepared using a traditional Mediterranean technique that keeps the calamari tender while developing incredible flavor. The lobster ravioli and shrimp Mozambique are also customer favorites that showcase our commitment to authentic preparation methods.

For first-time visitors to our Pinehurst, MA location, we recommend starting with our seafood antipasti to experience the range of our preparation styles, then moving to one of our signature pasta dishes that feature the day’s freshest catch. Our staff can guide you through wine pairings that complement each course perfectly.

The beauty of our menu is that it changes seasonally to highlight the best available seafood from New England waters, so there’s always something new to discover alongside our classic dishes that have been perfected over decades of service.

Yes, we have a dedicated private dining room that accommodates up to 45 guests for seated dinners, with space for up to 55 people for cocktail-style events. Our upstairs dining room features a full service bar and can be configured to meet your specific needs for any Pinehurst, MA celebration.

We also provide comprehensive catering services that bring our authentic Italian seafood throughout the Pinehurst, MA area. Whether it’s a corporate event, wedding, or family celebration, we can create custom menus that showcase our specialties while accommodating your group size and budget.

Our event planning team will work with you to handle all the details, from menu selection to service coordination, ensuring your special occasion reflects the same quality and attention to detail that defines our restaurant experience.

We receive fresh seafood deliveries multiple times per week from trusted New England suppliers, so freshness is consistent throughout our operating hours. However, our kitchen tends to be at its creative peak during dinner service when our full menu is available and we can showcase the day’s best selections.

Tuesday through Thursday evenings often feature live saxophone music, which adds to the authentic Italian atmosphere without overwhelming conversation. These nights are perfect for romantic dinners or intimate celebrations that Pinehurst, MA couples especially appreciate.

For the ultimate experience, we recommend making reservations for dinner service and asking your server about the day’s special preparations. We often create off-menu dishes featuring exceptional catches that arrive that day, giving you access to seafood at its absolute peak quality.

Our pricing reflects the quality of ingredients and level of preparation that goes into every dish we serve in Pinehurst, MA. While we’re not the cheapest option in the area, we offer exceptional value when you consider the authenticity of our cuisine, the freshness of our seafood, and the consistency of our preparation.

Massachusetts diners who appreciate authentic Italian seafood understand that quality ingredients and traditional preparation methods come at a premium. We’ve maintained our standards for over 20 years because we refuse to cut corners on sourcing or technique—something the discerning Pinehurst, MA dining community has come to expect.

What you’re paying for is access to the kind of seafood experience that would typically require a trip to the Mediterranean coast—prepared by chefs who understand these traditions and served in an atmosphere that honors the Italian approach to dining as a celebration, not just a meal.

Other Services we provide in Pinehurst