Italian Restaurant in Lexington, MA

Authentic Italian Dining Since 2004

Experience our award-winning Abruzzese cuisine with homemade pasta, fresh seafood, and signature dishes in Lexington’s most trusted Italian restaurant.
Delicious truffle pasta served with bread and herbs at a cozy outdoor dining spot.
Delicious Tartufo pizza with fresh basil and melted cheese, served at a cozy restaurant. Perfect for pizza lovers seeking gourmet flavors.

Best Italian Food Lexington MA

Real Italian Flavors, Right Here

You’re not settling for another generic Italian chain. You want the real thing – authentic flavors that actually transport you somewhere special. That’s exactly what you get here.

Every dish starts with traditional recipes from Italy’s Abruzzo region. We’re talking homemade pasta rolled fresh daily, seafood that tastes like it came straight from the Italian coast, and signature dishes you won’t find anywhere else in Lexington.

The difference is obvious from your first bite. This isn’t Italian-American food trying to be authentic – it’s the genuine article, prepared by our chefs who understand the tradition behind every sauce and seasoning.

Italian Dining Lexington Massachusetts

Two Decades of Authentic Excellence

Since 2004, we’ve been Lexington’s go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine. We’ve built our reputation on one simple principle: never compromise on quality or authenticity.

Our founder Anna Mountzuris created something special here – a restaurant that brings the flavors and traditions of Italy’s Abruzzo region directly to Massachusetts. We often bring in chefs from Abruzzo itself, ensuring every dish maintains its authentic character.

What makes us different from other Italian restaurants in Lexington? We focus on regional specialties you won’t find elsewhere. While others serve the same predictable menu, we offer unique Abruzzese dishes alongside perfectly executed classics. It’s Italian dining the way it’s meant to be – genuine, welcoming, and unforgettable.

Delicious truffle pasta dishes with fresh basil, grated cheese, and rich sauces, perfect for gourmet Italian dining experiences.

Italian Food Restaurant Lexington

From Kitchen to Table, Done Right

Everything starts with the ingredients. We source authentic Italian products and the freshest local ingredients, then prepare each dish to order using traditional techniques passed down through generations.

Our pasta is made fresh in-house daily. Our seafood arrives fresh and gets transformed into signature dishes like our famous Grilled Calamari. Each sauce is prepared from scratch, never from a jar or pre-made base.

When you arrive, you’ll experience the warmth of genuine Italian hospitality. Our dining room offers two distinct atmospheres – elegant upstairs dining with chandeliers and large windows, or the renovated downstairs space with an expansive bar and modern touches. Live saxophone jazz on select evenings adds to the authentic Italian ambiance.

Your meal arrives exactly as it should – hot, fresh, and prepared with the care that’s made us Lexington’s trusted Italian restaurant for nearly twenty years.

Delicious truffle pasta garnished with herbs, served on a white dish, perfect for gourmet dining.

Explore More Services

About Tartufo

Authentic Italian Restaurant Lexington

Everything You Want in Italian Dining

You’re getting more than just dinner here. You’re getting an authentic Italian experience that’s convenient, reliable, and genuinely special.

Our menu features signature dishes you won’t find at typical Italian restaurants in Lexington. The Veal Chop stuffed with prosciutto and fontina cheese, Lobster Ravioli in vodka pink sauce, and our famous Grilled Calamari represent the kind of regional specialties that set us apart. Every pasta dish uses our homemade noodles, and our seafood selections showcase the coastal influence of Abruzzo cuisine.

For special occasions, our private dining room accommodates up to 45 guests for seated dinners or 55 for cocktail events. Whether you’re celebrating an anniversary, hosting a business dinner, or planning a family gathering, we handle the details so you can focus on what matters.

Lexington residents have trusted us for nearly two decades because we deliver consistency without sacrificing authenticity. When you want real Italian food without the drive to Boston’s North End, this is where you come.

Delicious Tartufo cheese pizza topped with melted cheese and crispy crust, styled on rustic wooden table with fresh tomatoes.

What makes Tartufo different from other Italian restaurants in Lexington?

We specialize in authentic Abruzzese cuisine from Italy’s coastal region, not generic Italian-American dishes. Since 2004, we’ve maintained our commitment to traditional recipes and techniques, often bringing in chefs directly from Abruzzo to ensure authenticity.

Our homemade pasta is prepared fresh daily, and we focus on regional specialties like our signature Veal Chop and Grilled Calamari that you won’t find at typical Italian restaurants. While others serve predictable menus, we offer genuine Italian dining experiences rooted in specific regional traditions.

The difference shows in every detail – from our made-to-order approach using natural ingredients to our two distinct dining atmospheres and live jazz entertainment on select evenings.

Yes, our upstairs private dining room is perfect for special events and group celebrations. We accommodate up to 45 people for seated dinners and up to 55 guests for cocktail-style functions.

Whether you’re planning a birthday celebration, business dinner, wedding reception, or family gathering, we coordinate all the details to ensure a stress-free experience. Our private space features elegant décor with chandeliers, large windows, and a full-service bar.

We create custom menus tailored to your event’s needs and provide the same authentic Italian cuisine and attentive service that’s made us Lexington’s trusted choice for special occasions since 2004.

Our signature Grilled Calamari and bone-in Veal Chop stuffed with prosciutto and fontina cheese are guest favorites that showcase our Abruzzese specialties. The Lobster Ravioli in vodka pink sauce with crab meat and arugula is another standout dish.

For pasta lovers, our homemade Tagliatelle Carbonara with imported pancetta and our Pappardelle with scallops in vodka mascarpone sauce represent the authentic Italian preparation you’re looking for. Our seafood selections, including the Linguini with half lobster and the mixed seafood risotto, reflect the coastal influence of our regional cuisine.

Every dish is prepared to order using traditional techniques and the finest ingredients. Our portions are generous, and the quality remains consistent – that’s why guests have been returning for nearly twenty years.

We’re known throughout Lexington as the perfect destination for romantic dinners and special celebrations. Our upstairs dining room features elegant chandeliers, large windows with golden drapes, and an intimate atmosphere that’s ideal for date nights.

Live saxophone jazz on select evenings adds to the romantic ambiance, while our attentive service ensures your evening feels truly special. The lighting and décor create a warm, inviting atmosphere that’s sophisticated without being stuffy.

Many couples choose us for anniversaries, proposals, and milestone celebrations because we provide the kind of memorable dining experience that makes occasions feel significant. Our wine selection and authentic Italian cuisine complete the perfect evening out.

We provide the authentic Italian dining experience you’d expect from Boston’s North End, but with the convenience of staying local in Lexington. You get the same quality and authenticity without the drive, parking hassles, and time commitment of going into the city.

Our Abruzzese cuisine offers regional specialties that many North End restaurants don’t even serve. Plus, you can make reservations easily, enjoy comfortable parking, and have a more relaxed dining experience without the crowds and noise of tourist-heavy Boston locations.

For Lexington residents, we’ve been the trusted alternative to city dining for nearly two decades. You get authentic Italian food, professional service, and a welcoming atmosphere right in your own community.

Yes, we provide both takeout and delivery services for those times when you want our authentic Italian cuisine at home. Our made-to-order approach ensures your food maintains its quality whether you’re dining in or taking out.

Popular takeout items include our homemade pasta dishes, signature Grilled Calamari, and our various risotto selections. We package everything carefully to preserve the flavors and presentation you’d expect from dining in our restaurant.

During peak times, we recommend calling ahead to place your takeout order. This ensures your food is ready when you arrive and maintains the same high standards we’ve provided to Lexington families since 2004.

Other Services we provide in Lexington