Italian Restaurant in Sherborn, MA

Authentic Italian Dining in Your Neighborhood

Experience award-winning Abruzzese cuisine without the drive to Boston’s North End.
Delicious truffle pasta served with bread and herbs at a cozy outdoor dining spot.
Delicious Tartufo pizza with fresh basil and melted cheese, served at a cozy restaurant. Perfect for pizza lovers seeking gourmet flavors.

Authentic Italian Food Sherborn

Taste Italy Right Here in MetroWest

You shouldn’t have to choose between convenience and authenticity when you’re craving real Italian food. At Tartufo, you get both – genuine Abruzzese cuisine from Italy’s coastal region, served in the heart of Sherborn.

Our menu goes beyond typical Italian-American fare. We specialize in dishes from the Abruzzo region, featuring fresh seafood, signature truffle preparations, and house-made pasta that transport you straight to the Italian coast. Every plate reflects our commitment to authentic ingredients and traditional cooking methods.

When you dine with us, you’re not just getting dinner – you’re experiencing nearly two decades of Italian culinary tradition, perfected right here in your community.

Italian Restaurant Sherborn Massachusetts

Your Neighborhood Italian Haven Since 2004

We’ve been Sherborn’s go-to Italian restaurant for almost twenty years, and there’s a reason families keep coming back generation after generation. We’ve built our reputation on authentic Abruzzese cuisine, warm hospitality, and the kind of consistent quality that makes every meal memorable.

Founded by Anna Mountzuris with a vision to bring authentic Italian flavors to MetroWest, we’ve stayed true to that mission. Our chefs often come directly from the Abruzzo region of Italy, ensuring every dish maintains its authentic character and traditional preparation.

Located conveniently in your backyard, we’ve eliminated the need for Sherborn families to trek into Boston for exceptional Italian dining. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply craving a taste of Italy, we’ve been your trusted neighborhood destination for nearly two decades.

Delicious truffle pasta dishes with fresh basil, grated cheese, and rich sauces, perfect for gourmet Italian dining experiences.

Italian Dining Experience Sherborn

From Reservation to Last Bite

Your Tartufo experience begins the moment you make your reservation. We recommend booking ahead, especially for weekend dinners and special occasions, to ensure your preferred seating time.

When you arrive, you’ll choose between our two distinct dining atmospheres. Our elegant upstairs dining room features chandeliers and large windows with golden drapes – perfect for romantic dinners and celebrations. Downstairs, our newly renovated space offers a more casual feel with an expansive bar and modern touches, ideal for family dinners and catching up with friends.

Every dish is prepared to order using fresh, natural ingredients. Our signature items like the Grilled Calamari and truffle-infused pastas showcase the coastal flavors of Abruzzo, while classics like our house-made gnocchi and fresh seafood selections ensure there’s something special for every palate. Many evenings feature live saxophone music, adding an extra layer of ambiance to your dining experience.

Delicious truffle pasta garnished with herbs, served on a white dish, perfect for gourmet dining.

Explore More Services

About Tartufo

Best Italian Food Sherborn

What Makes Our Italian Different

Not all Italian restaurants are created equal, and Sherborn diners have come to expect something special from their neighborhood Italian spot. We deliver authentic Abruzzese cuisine – a coastal Italian tradition that emphasizes fresh seafood, house-made pastas, and the prized tartufo mushroom that gives our restaurant its name.

Our menu features specialties you won’t find at typical Italian restaurants. Think lobster ravioli in vodka pink sauce, frutti di mare risotto with fresh clams and mussels, and our signature veal chop stuffed with prosciutto and fontina cheese. We also accommodate dietary restrictions, offering gluten-free options for many of our most popular dishes.

For Sherborn families, we’re more than just dinner – we’re your celebration headquarters. Our upstairs private dining room hosts everything from birthday parties to graduation celebrations, accommodating up to 45 guests with full-service coordination. Local families have been marking their milestones here for years, creating memories that span generations in our welcoming atmosphere.

Delicious Tartufo cheese pizza topped with melted cheese and crispy crust, styled on rustic wooden table with fresh tomatoes.

What makes Tartufo different from other Italian restaurants in the area?

We specialize in authentic Abruzzese cuisine from Italy’s coastal region, which sets us apart from typical Italian-American restaurants. We focus on fresh seafood preparations, signature truffle dishes, and traditional recipes that many of our chefs bring directly from the Abruzzo region of Italy.

Our nearly 20-year presence in the community means we’ve perfected our craft while building lasting relationships with local families. Unlike chain restaurants or generic Italian spots, we maintain authentic preparation methods and source quality ingredients to create dishes like our signature Grilled Calamari and house-made lobster ravioli that you simply can’t find elsewhere in MetroWest.

We also offer two distinct dining experiences under one roof – elegant upstairs dining for special occasions and a more casual downstairs atmosphere with live music, giving you options based on your mood and the occasion.

Absolutely. Our upstairs private dining room can accommodate up to 45 guests for seated dinners or 55 for cocktail-style events. We provide full coordination services to make your celebration stress-free, whether you’re planning a birthday party, graduation celebration, business meeting, or family gathering.

We create custom menus tailored to your event’s needs and handle all the details so you can focus on enjoying time with your guests. Many Sherborn families have celebrated multiple generations of milestones in our private space.

For dietary accommodations, we offer gluten-free preparations for many of our most popular dishes, and our kitchen can work with various dietary restrictions. Just let us know about any special needs when you make your reservation, and we’ll ensure everyone at your table has delicious options to choose from.

Our signature dishes reflect the coastal Abruzzese tradition we’re known for. The Grilled Calamari is a guest favorite that showcases our seafood expertise, while our lobster ravioli in vodka pink sauce with crab meat and arugula represents the kind of sophisticated preparation you’d find in Italy’s coastal regions.

Our house-made gnocchi with tomato-basil sauce and fresh mozzarella is comfort food perfection, and the stuffed veal chop with prosciutto and fontina cheese demonstrates our commitment to premium ingredients and traditional techniques. For seafood lovers, our frutti di mare risotto and linguine alle vongole feature the freshest clams, mussels, and scallops.

Many dishes incorporate the tartufo mushroom that gives our restaurant its name – these rare truffles from the Abruzzo region add an authentic touch that elevates familiar Italian flavors into something truly special. Our chefs prepare everything to order, so each dish arrives with the vibrant flavors and perfect textures that define genuine Italian cuisine.

We’ve designed Tartufo to work beautifully for both intimate occasions and family gatherings. Our upstairs dining room creates the perfect romantic atmosphere with elegant chandeliers, large windows, and sophisticated décor that makes every date night feel special. Many evenings feature live saxophone music that adds to the ambiance without overwhelming conversation.

For families, our downstairs area offers a more relaxed environment where kids feel welcome while parents can still enjoy exceptional food and service. The newly renovated space features comfortable seating and a more casual vibe that works well for everything from Sunday family dinners to catching up with friends.

We’ve found that many couples start as date night diners and eventually bring their growing families back to celebrate birthdays, anniversaries, and other milestones. Our staff takes pride in recognizing returning guests and making every visit feel like a special occasion, whether you’re on a first date or celebrating your 25th wedding anniversary with the grandkids in tow.

We strongly recommend making reservations ahead of time, especially for weekend dinners, holiday periods, and any time you’re planning to celebrate a special occasion. Friday and Saturday evenings typically book up several days in advance, particularly for our preferred dining times between 6:30 and 8:00 PM.

For private events in our upstairs dining room, we suggest booking at least two to three weeks ahead, especially during popular celebration seasons like graduation time, the holiday season, and wedding season. This gives us adequate time to plan your custom menu and coordinate all the details that make your event memorable.

If you’re flexible with your timing, weeknight dinners and earlier seating times often have more availability. You can always call day-of to check for last-minute openings – we do our best to accommodate walk-ins when possible, but reservations guarantee you won’t be disappointed, especially when you’re looking forward to that perfect Italian dinner.

We’re perfectly positioned to serve Sherborn and the broader MetroWest community without the hassle of driving into Boston. Located in nearby Newton Centre, we’re easily accessible from Sherborn, Natick, Framingham, Dover, and surrounding towns – giving you authentic Italian dining just minutes from home.

Many of our guests tell us they used to make the trek to Boston’s North End for quality Italian food, but now they can enjoy the same level of authenticity and sophistication right in their neighborhood. We offer convenient parking and easy access, so you can focus on enjoying your meal rather than dealing with city traffic and parking challenges.

For Sherborn families especially, we’ve become the go-to spot for celebrations and special dinners because you get restaurant-quality Italian cuisine without the travel time. Whether you’re planning a quick weeknight dinner or a special celebration, you can be seated and enjoying authentic Italian flavors within minutes of leaving your house.

Other Services we provide in Sherborn