Steak Restaurant in Lexington, MA

Premium Steaks Meet Authentic Italian Excellence

Where perfectly grilled steaks blend with traditional Italian mastery, creating unforgettable dining experiences in the heart of Lexington.
Close-up of a person cutting into a gourmet truffle steak at a restaurant, highlighting fine dining experience.
Delicious steak topped with herbs and complemented by truffle, ready to enjoy.

Fine Dining Steakhouse Lexington MA

Taste the Difference Quality Makes

You’re not just ordering dinner—you’re investing in an experience that delivers on every promise. Our grilled beef tenderloin arrives perfectly cooked with port wine and balsamic reduction, paired with seasonal vegetables that actually complement the meat instead of competing with it.

Each steak is selected for quality, not convenience. When you’re celebrating something important or treating yourself to what you deserve, you’ll taste why our guests return again and again.

The difference shows in details most restaurants skip: the sear that locks in flavor, the timing that ensures your steak arrives at the perfect temperature, the sides that enhance rather than distract.

Award-Winning Steakhouse Lexington Massachusetts

Twenty Years of Authentic Excellence

We’ve been serving Lexington and the Greater Boston area since 2004, earning our reputation one perfectly prepared meal at a time. Founded by Anna Mountzuris, we’ve built our name on authentic Italian tradition combined with the steakhouse experience you’re looking for.

Our 4.5-star reputation comes from understanding what matters: quality ingredients, proper technique, and service that makes your evening special without being intrusive. We’re the restaurant locals recommend when they want to impress someone.

Located in Newton with easy access from Lexington, we’ve become the go-to destination for celebrations, date nights, and those occasions when only the best will do.

Close-up of a chef slicing a perfectly cooked steak with black truffle slices on a wooden cutting board.

Premium Steak Dining Experience Lexington

From Selection to Your Table

Your steak experience starts with our careful selection of premium cuts, chosen for marbling, tenderness, and flavor. We don’t cut corners on quality because we know you can taste the difference.

Our chefs prepare each steak using traditional techniques that bring out the meat’s natural flavors. Whether you prefer your beef tenderloin medium-rare or your veal chop perfectly pink, we time everything so your entire table is served together, hot and exactly as ordered.

The experience extends beyond the steak itself. Our sommelier-selected wines complement your choice, our sides are prepared fresh to order, and our service team ensures your evening flows smoothly from appetizer to dessert.

Juicy steak sliced with a crispy crust, served with greens and whole peppercorns on a white plate.

Explore More Services

About Tartufo

Complete Steakhouse Menu Lexington MA

More Than Just Great Steaks

While our steaks anchor the menu, your complete dining experience includes our signature appetizers, fresh seafood, and homemade pasta options. Our grilled calamari and beef carpaccio start your meal perfectly, while our lobster ravioli offers an elegant alternative to steak.

Lexington diners appreciate our full-service bar featuring premium wines, craft cocktails, and after-dinner selections. Our live saxophone jazz on select evenings creates the sophisticated atmosphere that makes ordinary nights feel special.

For private celebrations, our upstairs dining room accommodates up to 45 guests with dedicated service and customized menus. Whether you’re planning a business dinner or anniversary celebration, we handle the details so you can focus on your guests.

Juicy grilled steak garnished with herbs, served on a wire rack at Tartufo, emphasizing gourmet Italian cuisine.

What makes Tartufo different from other steak restaurants in Lexington?

We combine authentic Italian culinary tradition with premium steakhouse quality, something you won’t find at typical chain steakhouses. Since 2004, we’ve been preparing our signature dishes like bone-in double-cut veal chop stuffed with prosciutto and fontina cheese, topped with mushrooms and port wine reduction.

Our award-winning reputation comes from using only the freshest ingredients and traditional preparation methods. While other restaurants focus on volume, we focus on the details that make your dining experience memorable.

You’ll also experience our live saxophone jazz music, creating an ambiance that transforms dinner into an event worth celebrating.

Yes, we strongly recommend making reservations, especially for weekend dining and special occasions. You can book online through our website or call us directly at the restaurant.

For weekend evenings, we suggest booking at least a week in advance, particularly if you prefer specific seating times. Our most popular reservation times fill quickly, especially during holiday seasons and special events.

If you’re planning a celebration or need our private dining room for larger parties, we recommend booking several weeks ahead to ensure availability and allow time for menu customization.

Our grilled beef tenderloin with port wine and balsamic sauce remains our signature steak, served with seasonal vegetables and mashed potatoes. The tenderloin is known for its exceptional tenderness and subtle flavor that pairs beautifully with our house-made sauce.

Our bone-in double-cut veal chop is another guest favorite, stuffed with prosciutto and fontina cheese, then topped with mushrooms and port wine reduction. This dish represents our Italian heritage while delivering the steakhouse experience you’re seeking.

We prepare all steaks using traditional grilling techniques that create the perfect sear while maintaining the interior temperature you prefer. Each cut is hand-selected for quality and aged properly before preparation.

Our steak entrées range from moderate to premium pricing, reflecting the quality of ingredients and preparation you’ll receive. Each steak comes with carefully chosen accompaniments—our beef tenderloin includes seasonal vegetables and mashed potatoes, while our veal chop is served with roasted potatoes and vegetables.

We believe in transparent pricing without hidden fees or surprise charges. What you see on the menu is what you’ll pay, and portions are generous enough to satisfy without requiring additional sides unless you choose them.

For special occasions, we offer wine pairings that complement your steak selection, and our sommelier can recommend options at various price points to match your preferences and budget.

Absolutely. Our kitchen can accommodate most dietary restrictions with advance notice, including gluten-free preparations and modifications for food allergies. We take these requests seriously and work with you to ensure a safe, enjoyable dining experience.

For steaks, we can adjust preparation methods and seasonings to meet your dietary needs. Our chefs are experienced in preparing dishes for guests with various restrictions without compromising flavor or presentation.

We recommend calling ahead when making your reservation to discuss specific dietary needs, allowing our kitchen team to prepare properly and suggest menu options that work best for your requirements.

Yes, we provide convenient parking for our guests, eliminating the stress of finding street parking in the area. Our Newton location is easily accessible from Lexington, typically just a short drive from Lexington center.

We’re located at 22 Union Street in Newton, with clear signage and easy access from major roads. The drive from Lexington typically takes 10-15 minutes depending on traffic and your starting point.

For guests using ride-sharing services, our location is well-known to drivers, and we’re happy to provide specific directions or landmarks when you make your reservation to ensure you find us easily.

Other Services we provide in Lexington